EXCLUSIVE: Andrew McCullough, former Broncos star, perplexed by ‘absurd’ storyline unsettling the club

Andrew McCullough, a legendary figure for the Broncos, has shed light on the intense focus the Brisbane club has been under, targeting what he describes as “absurd” criticism directed at them earlier in the season.

The Broncos ended a 19-year premiership drought last season, clinching the grand final in Michael Maguire’s inaugural year as head coach.

However, despite that tremendous achievement in October, by March the team and coach found themselves facing significant pressure and unfounded critiques from external sources, notably former player Gorden Tallis.

Tallis embarked on a campaign against his former team, Maguire, and captain Adam Reynolds over several weeks on his platforms with Fox League and Triple M.

This criticism intensified after superstar prop Payne Haas declared he would leave Red Hill to join South Sydney at the end of the year, sparking a narrative that Maguire was overworking his players and had lost the respect of many within the squad.

Following that, the team travelled to England, where they were surprisingly defeated by Hull KR in the World Club Challenge.

Upon their return to Australia, the Broncos suffered a heavy defeat at the hands of Penrith in the opening round, followed by a shocking loss to the Eels in round two.

After three straight defeats, calls for Maguire’s head intensified, but since then, the team has bounced back, winning five out of six matches despite being hampered by a severe injury crisis.

Even with a significant portion of their starting lineup missing in the last fortnight, Brisbane managed to secure victories against the formidable Tigers and the Bulldogs.

As a result, Broncos supporters are now retaliating against those who doubted Maguire and his squad just weeks prior.

“I, for one, have not heard any whispers of infighting or anything of that nature,” noted Nine commentator Peter Psaltis on Wide World of Sports’ QLDER.

Catch the 2026 NRL season live and free on Nine and 9Now.

“What has transpired over the last few weeks should silence many of the critics down south who claim the club is in disarray, with players at odds with the coach and other such nonsense.”

“The team has demonstrated enough resilience through the challenges they’ve faced recently to show that they are committed to back-to-back premierships.”

McCullough commenced his NRL journey with the Broncos in 2008, participating in 260 matches for the esteemed club before departing in 2020 for a brief period with the Knights, then two seasons with the Dragons before hanging up his boots.

Having undergone both tough times and moments of success, including reaching the grand final in 2015, he is well-acquainted with the pressures that come with sporting a Broncos jersey and the spotlight it attracts.

Now involved with the club, he aims to help younger players navigate the intense scrutiny they might face.

“This is about educating the younger players on what playing for Brisbane involves, especially being a Bronco,” McCullough explained to QLDER.

“It’s often either a rollercoaster of success or disappointment, with little room in the middle.”

“When you’re riding the highs, you receive praise, but must also withstand criticism during the lows, which is amplified due to the club’s prominence.”

“In my experience at other clubs, the level of media attention during training and the speculative reporting is simply not the same.”

“There are ups and downs, but it’s essential to keep a level head and overcome it all.”

“It was quite absurd earlier this year to see such speculation surrounding a club that had just lifted the trophy; I’ve never encountered anything like that.”

“While it may serve well for media narratives, it certainly wasn’t justified.”

Now, the beleaguered Broncos head south to face the Roosters in round nine.