Perilous Outcomes for Two NRL Clubs if Jarome Luai Decides to Cash In and Move to PNG

Securing Jarome Luai’s signature would represent a significant achievement for the PNG Chiefs, especially if the star of the Wests Tigers is swayed by the substantial post-tax salary increase and the prospect of being the prominent figure of a brand-new franchise.

The talented half-back is in a privileged position where he can activate a one-year extension on his existing $1.2 million-a-season contract with the Tigers, ensuring his stay at Concord until 2027, all while weighing the pros and cons of a potential overseas move in 2028.

Given the NRL’s contract valuation system, it’s probable that the Chiefs would need to at least match Luai’s current $1.2 million-a-year deal within the salary cap for any contract to be registered. If an agreement is struck on that figure, Luai would earn $1.2 million annually for the duration of his contract with the Chiefs, assuming there are no salary increases.

Should he remain with the Tigers or any other Australian-based NRL club, Luai would earn $670,000 a year on the same deal. To match the $1.2 million, he would need to negotiate a contract worth nearly $2.2 million with any club outside of the Chiefs.

As the saying goes, money speaks volumes, and the Tigers may end up regretting their decision to permit Luai’s management to incorporate clauses in his contract that essentially grant him free agency for a portion of each season.

The ball is now firmly in Luai’s court; should he choose to leave, the implications will be substantial.

Impacts of Luai’s Departure on the Tigers

In simple terms, Luai’s presence has dramatically altered the fortunes of a team historically known for finishing at the bottom of the ladder. During his inaugural season, the four-time premiership winner spearheaded a minor revival, leading to a respectable 13th-place finish.

After eight rounds of the current season, they sit third with 12 points—a position that accurately reflects their strong performances. Earlier this month, Andrew Johns suggested they are a genuine contender for the premiership and are playing with the kind of confidence typically associated with the league’s powerhouse teams.

While the turnaround is largely credited to Benji Marshall, there’s no denying that Luai’s arrival has infused the squad with the confidence essential for success in the NRL.

Catch the 2026 NRL season live and free on Nine and 9Now.

Removing the 29-year-old from the equation would diminish much of the team’s attacking flair. While the Tigers boast a roster filled with promising young talent, it’s Luai who commands the big bucks for a reason.

Even if he remains, Billy Slater has cautioned about the potential distractions that could derail the Tigers’ 2026 season, sparked by Luai’s visit to PNG. Slater advised Luai to address these concerns with the team.

With the Samoan superstar as the team’s face, it becomes considerably easier to convey to other players that the club is cultivating something special and is on the verge of competing for a premiership. This narrative should assist in retaining coveted players like fullback Jahream Bula and could potentially allow for lesser-paid mid-tier players who aspire to play for a winning outfit.

If Luai departs at the end of next season, coinciding with co-captain Api Koroisau turning 35, it would feel as if the club is back at square one in its rebuilding phase, cruelly robbing a long-suffering fanbase of what could have been a promising premiership run.

A silver lining exists, however, as several high-calibre halves will be off contract when Luai potentially exits, providing the Tigers with the opportunity to invest the $1.2 million they would save into pursuing players like Nathan Cleary, Matt Burton, Sam Walker, or Blaize Talagi.

If they fail to secure those marquee names, they will have no choice but to rely on the development of players like Latu Fainu and Jock Madden over the coming two years.

The Contrast with the Perth Bears

Finding a player of Luai’s calibre is a rare occurrence, and if the Chiefs succeed in acquiring him, they would immediately surpass a Bears squad preparing to enter the competition a year earlier.

Alarmingly, with just ten months until they debut, Perth has secured only one regular starter and has not been successful in attracting a superstar talent.

The Bears’ most notable names include Tyran Wishart, Siosifa Talakai, Nick Meaney, Scott Sorensen, Josh Curran, Liam Henry, and Toby Sexton.

Among them, only Meaney is a consistent NRL starter. The other players, with the exception of Sexton—who is currently in the Super League—have typically been valuable contributors but not regular starters. While Wishart has been touted as a potential utility for Origin and Talakai has filled a bench role for the Blues, they have all come to the Bears seeking more prominent roles. A spine composed of Meaney, Wishart, Sexton, and an undecided hooker lacks the star quality necessary, and as of now, it appears unlikely they will be backed by a formidable forward pack.

The Chiefs are reportedly on the verge of announcing their first major signing, with the NRL’s all-time top try-scorer, Alex Johnston, close to finalising a deal for the 2028 season. If Luai also comes onboard, the Chiefs would boast the foundations of a potent backline 18 months ahead of their inaugural preseason.

Conversely, the Perth Bears, with only 16 players committed for next season, present a concerning contrast. Their recent turmoil leading to the departure of the head of football and questions surrounding the appointment of Mal Meninga as their inaugural coach add to the uncertainty.

According to senior Nine reporter Danny Weidler’s column in The Sydney Morning Herald, the NRL’s initial enthusiasm for Meninga is waning, prompting Peter V’landys and his colleagues to contemplate how the Bears can be made competitive in their formative years.

Theoretically, Perth should offer a more appealing prospect for NRL players compared to Papua New Guinea, thanks to its beaches and quality of life. However, the allure of tax-free incomes seems to be tipping the scale in favour of the Chiefs.

Sealing Luai’s signature would be a remarkable achievement for the Chiefs, simultaneously highlighting the Bears’ ongoing struggle to attract top talent as the NRL’s next expansion team begins to feel somewhat neglected.